I see no value whatsoever in the Oscars, but, as an exercise, here are some brief thoughts on those (feature-length) nominated films that I have seen.
The Artist (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Writing (Original Screenplay), Best Original Score, Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design, Best Film Editing)
What’s perhaps most surprising about The Artist is that it works at all. Full props for making a successful silent film in the 21st century. Considering this it’s not surprising at all that it’s garnered so many awards and nominations which are probably not actually entirely related to its worth. Even so, it’s certainly enjoyable.
A Better Life (Best Actor)
From the director of Twilight: New Moon, no less, would you believe it. Well, actually, yes. It’s not a great film, but neither is it terrible. It’s noteworthy for its Hispanic focus and acting but little else.
Bridesmaids (Best Supporting Actress, Best Writing (Original Screenplay))
So, I watched Bridesmaids, did I? And I’m admitting it? Yes, actually, to both. And I’m not saying I actually laughed, but still, at least 1.34 times better than the average Hollywood comedy. And that, from me, is high praise indeed.
A Cat in Paris (Best Animated Feature)
Not actually that good, I think people’ve been fooled by the fact that it’s in French and that people drew it. Much of the voice-acting is wooden, the timing stilted, and it’s highly derivative. While the pictures may have looked good in a picture book, they don’t work in motion. I guess people did draw it though, that’s got to be worth something, right? Ultimately it’s a little too derivative, and the timing misses its beats a little too often to make it truly immersive but (mostly) its aesthetically pleasing and possibly I’m being too hard on it, taken as a kids film it’s pretty good.
Chico & Rita (Best Animated Feature)
Technically a bit of a shambles, but even so, good fun, particularly musically.
The Descendants (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Bet Writing (Adapted Screenplay), Best Film Editing)
Boring. When Hollywood makes a film in which someone takes two hours to die we’re supposed to think it’s amazing and touching and wonderful, but it isn’t, it’s just generic and boring. Even the writers seem to have realised this, throwing in an ecological sub-plot, which just serves to remind us how generic and boring the whole thing is.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 (Best Art Direction, Best Makeup, Best Visual Effects)
Well, I loved it, but honestly that has nothing to do with its worth as a film (minimal). I felt the last two Potter films did a particularly good job of coping with the books, although I’m aware many disagree. Even so, there were, I think, some obvious beats missed, and this one missed some golden opportunities for emotional cinematic moments, largely because of the pursuit of spectacle. It is, I think, like most-all of the Potter films, a bit of a mess. I still cried though.
Kung Fu Panda 2 (Best Animated Feature)
While it gets pretty high marks for its character animation there’s not much else going for it, I guess maybe if you haven’t learned to walk yet.
Midnight in Paris (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Writing (Original Screenplay), Best Art Direction)
Awful, truly, abominably awful. But then I am incapable of seeing even a modicum of worth in anything Woody Allen does, so I’m probably not the best source for an opinion on this.
Pina (Best Feature-length Documentary)
Awesome, amazing, best film I saw in 2011. Glorious, sublime, poetry. Love. Etc. Also, only film I’ve seen worth watching in 3D.
Puss in Boots (Animated Feature Film)
This is basically an appalling film. I struggle to find anything good to say about it. The animation is shoddy, the writing is lame, the music is diabolical. I could go on, but why bother.
Rango (Best Animated Feature)
Johnny Depp in snooze mode, story boring, moral painfully driven in to the centre of the forehead with Thor’s oh so subtle hammer (not a reference to the film Thor, which doesn’t appear on this list, and I haven’t seen). On the other hand, some jokes half-good and much better character design than any other CG animation on this list.
A Separation (Best Writing (Original Screenplay), Best Foreign Language Film)
A superbly acted and paced drama and absolutely revealing, both about Iran and as an examination of the complexities of relationships. It’s gained a load of awards and nominations and topped a bunch of best-of-2011 lists, and rightly so. Whether it’s quite the classic we’re being led to believe I’m not entirely sure, but for sure it’s an insightful and revealing film and it’s pretty astonishing that it got made at all.
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Best Actor, Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay), Best Original Score)
I wrote quite an extensive review of this in my little black notebook immediately after seeing it, but it didn’t seem worth posting. I don’t have anything clever to say here really. I enjoyed it. A great exercise in adaptation of a complex story from page to screen, and a textbook creation of period milieu, although, frankly, it was a little forced at times – In every shot the camera seems to subtly pan past some expertly placed piece of authentic set dressing. Also fell afoul of the current preoccupation with absurdly shallow depth of field. Nevertheless, good writing, good acting, it’s a lot more than you get from the majority.
Transformers: Dark of the Moon (Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Visual Effects)
Bilge. Why did I even bother to watch it? You say. Well, only because I was in Chicago when they shot bits of it, and I wanted to match reality to celluloid. It wasn’t worth the time wasted.
The Tree of Life (Best Picture, Cinematography, Best Director)
Well, as most have commented, The Tree of Life is nothing if not ambitious. And reviews seem to fall into two camps: Is the ambition well placed, or is it childish pretension? The consensus seems to fall in the former camp. I can’t be bothered to weigh in on this debate and will simply say, it’s great to see Douglas Trumbull working again and creating what is essentially, if you ignore the boring bits with people in, far more of a sequel to 2001 than 2010 ever was.
















